• Welcome to National Homebrew Club Ireland. Please login or sign up.
May 12, 2025, 09:45:24 PM

News:

Want to Join up ? Simply follow the instructions here
Not a forum user? Now you can join the discussion on Discord


O Shea's Pale Ale & Irish Stout Review - Aldi

Started by GrahamR, May 06, 2014, 10:06:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

GrahamR

Made by Carlow Brewing company for the Aldi Company, these are the slightly more affordable little sister of the O Haras range

The Pale pours that lovely golden colour of O Haras with a lovely fresh hit of hops in the nose. At 4.3% it is a very sessionable beer, perfect for a Summers day if they ever arrive. Highly carbonated, perhaps overly so but it does maintain a head to the bottom of the glass which is always a plus for me.
Not quite as fresh tasting as the O Hara's and I would imagine containing less IBU's which is where I imagine the savings in brewing come but at €1.89 you cant really go wrong. Considering O Hara's tend to be closer to the €3 mark in most local offies, this could be your new best friend at the weekends, other then homebrew of course.

The stout is my personal preference of the two. Pouring to my eye a slightly off black, it retains a lovely coffee coloured head as you drink. You immediately get the hit of roasted grains which always reminds me of proper freshly ground coffee. Again is more carbonated then most stouts tend to be but it doesn't harm your enjoyment. At a similar price and ABV to the Pale you can take your pick between the two.

If you had both the O Shea's and O Hara's in front of you playing a game of Russian Roulette, I like most would be hoping that O Hara's was the victor but O Shea's definitely has its merits.

Think of it as shopping in TK Maxx over Brown Thomas's. You are getting the product at a reduced cost as its not quite as good as the current season, but its pretty damn close and that will do most of us.
Lifes Too Short To Not Make Beer

Fermenter 1 - Turquoise Lunar Showing

Fermenter 2 - Vitalift Cider

DEMPSEY

I personally prefer the O'Shea's red over the O'Hara's red :)
Dei miscendarum discipulus
Forgive us our Hangovers as we forgive those who hangover against us

Chris

Primary: Back to Black Again (Michael Jackson stout)
Secondary:
Conditioning:  Breac Donn Imperial Amber Ale
Drinking: Cascade Reaction Amber Ale, Fear Gorm Irish stout, lonesome pilgrim pale ale
Planned: imperial stout, finlandia kit hack

brenmurph

generally stout is bang on...chocolatty, roasty, creamy.... few nights ago we wernt too impressed, but generally its great

GrahamR

Not a fan of red in general and have never bothered with the O Hara's so cant compare. Are there any other breweries in Ireland that make beer for other companies ala O Haras
Lifes Too Short To Not Make Beer

Fermenter 1 - Turquoise Lunar Showing

Fermenter 2 - Vitalift Cider

Chris


Quote from: GrahamR on May 06, 2014, 11:03:52 PM
Not a fan of red in general and have never bothered with the O Hara's so cant compare. Are there any other breweries in Ireland that make beer for other companies ala O Haras
you should try the Bru Rua it's a red but a hoppy one
Primary: Back to Black Again (Michael Jackson stout)
Secondary:
Conditioning:  Breac Donn Imperial Amber Ale
Drinking: Cascade Reaction Amber Ale, Fear Gorm Irish stout, lonesome pilgrim pale ale
Planned: imperial stout, finlandia kit hack

Greg2013

Quote from: GrahamR on May 06, 2014, 11:03:52 PM
Not a fan of red in general and have never bothered with the O Hara's so cant compare. Are there any other breweries in Ireland that make beer for other companies ala O Haras

Bulmers makes the apple and pear ciders for Aldi. ;D
"Be polite, be professional, but have a plan to kill everybody you meet."  Gen. James 'Mad Dog' Mattis USMC(Ret.)

Samael

I like Pale Ale and Red, but Stout is awful for me ???
..::Tomasz::..